Register Now!

"We were fifteen minutes into drinks, when she said..."

Vitals

Male, 28, Writer

on a date with

Female, 27, Film Student

First Date at Park Slope Dive Bar New York, NY

In celebration of meeting new people and the whole kaleidoscope of human experience that can come out of that, we're instituting a new column where Hooksexup readers can share the details of their latest date. It's like a post-date conversation with a friend. If you're interested in sharing your date with us, we'd love to hear about it.

ACT 1: "You don't want your first date to be kayaking down the Amazon or whatever…"

So how'd you end up on this date?
This girl wrote to me on a dating site — very blunt, to the point, "we should hang out sometime." But funny.

Tell us what you knew (or thought you knew) about her before you met up. Did you Google her? (Admit it.)
I didn't know much, because her profile was about as chatty as her messages (ie, not very). But she was funny. She talked about being a film student and animating a web series, both of which were attractive/interesting to me. She said that she'd just finished her first screenplay and then had a funny disclaimer about how ominous it sounds when people say that — pretty charming.

What did you plan to do? Whose bright idea was it?
Nothing too fancy — we just figured we'd get a drink and go from there. You never know how well you're going to connect to someone, so you don't want your first date to be kayaking down the Amazon or whatever.

Beauty is only skin deep, but how'd your date look? Were you immediately attracted or turned off by her in some way? 
She was cute — tall, kind of willowy, with interesting features. Not gorgeous, but striking. Definitely had the look of a one-time teenage stoner, which I cherish in a woman.

ACT 2: "Do you want to come back to my place and eat chocolate on a baguette and play Portal 2?"

So, what exactly did you end up doing? Take us through the sequence of events.
Well, here's where it got funny. We were just chatting at the bar, I was asking her about her day job (tutoring) and her screenplay (time travel!), and we were maybe fifteen minutes into drinks, when she said, "Hey, I'm really tired, and I'm really hungry. Do you want to come back to my place and eat chocolate on a baguette and play Portal 2?" Obviously, my answer to that one was yes. So we paid up, grabbed food at a bodega, headed back to her apartment, and played Portal 2 on her giant projector. 

What surprised you most about your date?
It surprised me that she invited me over fifteen minutes after she met me, I'll tell you that.

Did anything really funny happen? (And were you laughing together?) How about anything awkward?
Besides the funniness of the fact that we were playing it at all, Portal 2 turned out to be pretty hilarious and fun. 

Be frank: did your date get more or less attractive as the night went on?
She was odd and funny from the beginning, but I only liked her more while we were sitting there in the dark playing video games. Portal 2 is about as science/math-nerdy as you can get, and she was a definite science/math nerd, which I found really attractive. 

Conversation-wise, did you hold anything back? What might you have blurted out if you'd had one more drink? Unless you did have one more drink. 
Well, I wasn't really holding back conversation-wise — I was just having a good time joking around with her. But I was holding back making-out-wise, because, you know, I'd just met her.

ACT 3: "Read between the lines!"

How'd it end? Polite hug? Taxi sex? Fistfight? 
Unfortunately, that's kind of the downer ending. After about forty-five minutes of playing video games on a couch in the dark with this girl, I was about ready to make a move, when she was like, "Okay, I'm going to bed!" and showed me to the door. We kissed goodnight, but that was it. 

Would you go out again? And if so, what might you want to do? 
Well, I was kind of bemused by the whole thing, but I'd enjoyed it, so the next day I texted her and was like, "Hey, that was fun. We should play video games again sometime," and she never responded! Which I wasn't too upset about — but I did think it was remarkable to invite someone into your apartment after fifteen minutes of conversation if you're apparently not that psyched about them anyway.

If you went out again, what would you do differently? Or did you ace it, you sly devil? 
If we went out again, I probably would've made a move once we were in the dark together. But really, I just got caught off-guard. 

Time for a little objectivity: how close do you think your date's version of this story would be to yours? And what might they differ on? 
That's a little hard to figure. Two scenarios: one, "That guy wasn't very good at conversation/video games," or two, "I invited this numbskull into my apartment in a transparent offer of casual sex, and he unbelievably failed to take the hint. Come on, 'Portal 2?' Read between the lines! Now stop asking me questions — you're distracting me from my time-travel screenplay!" Now that I think about it, probably the latter.

Thanks for your time. Anything you'd like to add? 
The cake is a lie.

Have a great dating story you want to share with us? Tell us all about it.

Find a date of your own

&

Commentarium (26 Comments)

Feb 21 12 - 9:30am
Buck Nasty

Strangely, this sort of stuff is all too common. I've been on 5 dates with on-liners in the past 4 weeks and 3 of them were like this. Chicks that catch you off guard then you never hear from them again. It is strange as fuck.

Feb 23 12 - 2:52pm
mp

You realize you're the common thread here, yes?

Feb 21 12 - 11:47am
JCF

Someone forward enough to invite you to her apartment after 15 minutes would also probably be forward enough to initiate casual sex if that's what she wanted. Seeing that she didn't, chances are she's just crazy. :-)

Feb 21 12 - 12:15pm
BrosephofArimathea

You obviously weren't thinking with portals.

Feb 26 12 - 12:37am
Genya

Maybe he should burn her house down with lemons.

Feb 21 12 - 12:20pm
xdl

Freudian analysis on the whole "Portal" thing is almost too easy...

Feb 21 12 - 12:56pm
jaycee

The cake is a cigar.

Feb 21 12 - 2:19pm
Sarah

@Buck Nasty and JCF
I'm a girl. The kind of girl who would initiate messaging contact with a guy on a dating website if he seemed interesting.
I don't get why you think she seems crazy. My take on this is that she thought he seemed interesting online, didn't feel like hanging out at the bar making awkward conversation over drinks, so took it back to her place. (Which admittedly I'm not sure I would do so soon as I am skittish about strangers from the Internet knowing where I live.)
Perhaps she figured out if they had chemistry he might make a move. He didn't.
Orm she just found him less interesting once they'd hung out for a while than she'd hoped she would. The latter happens with 90 percent of my Internet dates.

Feb 21 12 - 7:18pm
the author

Just to say--this was my story--she didn't seem crazy to me.

Feb 21 12 - 7:48pm
Sarah

No worries. Didn't mean to imply that you thought that. My comment was more directed at commenters "JCF" and "Buck Nasty"

Feb 21 12 - 8:03pm
JCF

Fair enough.

Feb 21 12 - 7:05pm
SB

I'm not of the opinion the girl was crazy. It's just the crazy mating dance we all attempt to stumble through to get whatever goal we're looking for.
I haven't played Portal 2...maybe it's much more fun with 2 people...then again maybe the guy did miss the signals.

God knows I've been given the clue and totally missed it (dumbass!) We're talking, "So, Ilive right around the corner...wanna come over?" duh!

Feb 21 12 - 7:51pm
Kewpie

She probably just didn't think you were gorgeous enough.

Feb 21 12 - 7:57pm
the author

I'd have settled for "striking." :)

Feb 21 12 - 9:48pm
Kewpie

Probably not "striking" enough either. You probably came off like an entitled milquetoast who wouldn't be good in bed. Girls want someone who desires them --not some wishy washy schlub who doesn't get simple cues.

Feb 22 12 - 12:33am
author

It's certainly possible, although it's also possible that you're wildly projecting.

Feb 22 12 - 1:01pm
OMG!

> schlub who doesn't get simple cues
It's those same simple cues that get men accused of date-rape.

Feb 22 12 - 1:44pm
Foofta

Kewpie. Short run. Long peer. Go.

Feb 21 12 - 10:19pm
thinkywritey

Finding "we should hang out sometime" to be a funny opening line may indicate that you are too easy to impress. Going up to her apartment to do what she was going to do by herself anyway definitely indicates that you are way too easy to impress. Not too surprising she didn't continue to respond... She probably was just bored that night (in general, not necessarily with you) and not really interested in "dating." Online sites are full of people like that.

Feb 22 12 - 12:36am
author

That wasn't the entirety of her opening message, but yes, I probably am too easy to impress.

Feb 21 12 - 10:19pm
Diana

"Definitely had the look of a one-time teenage stoner, which I cherish in a woman."

Syntactically sound.

Feb 22 12 - 1:01am
Litsa

Thanks for sharing this. As we all know, dating can be terribly awkward or confusing and it's cool you're honest about all of it.

That said, regardless of whatever chemistry you two had, always say yes to chocolate and baguettes.

Feb 22 12 - 7:54pm
rumy

yea that is funny (on how it ended) she will probably txt u back in a week or two

Feb 23 12 - 8:30pm
Hank Bell

I'm guessing that your date was an Asperger's Syndrome girl, taking you to her comfort level; and when you didn't act soon enough in the dark, she felt awkward and....ended the date.

Feb 26 12 - 3:33pm
JCB

I've been that girl. Not with the Portal 2, but the...being forward enough to make it really easy for the guy to make a move, but not forward enough to make a move myself. And then when he doesn't, it's a bit awkward and confusing and you decide to call it a night. Looking back on those times as an older and wiser woman, most of the time the guy was just working up his Hooksexup and taking too long.

Feb 27 12 - 10:16pm
SC

portal 2 AND chocolate on a baguette? I wouldn't kiss her after that.

Now you say something

Incorrect please try again
Enter the words above: Enter the numbers you hear: