Register Now!

Seven Mensches I’d Like to Schtup

In honor of the High Holidays, the choicest of the chosen people.

By Amanda Green

This Friday, the Jewish High Holidays come to an end. Before it's time to atone, we should celebrate, and where better to start than the mensch? Yiddish for "stand-up guy,” the mensch is admirable for his accomplishments, his charm, and his moral fiber. These mensches also happen to be totally gorgeous. 

Spike Jonze

Spike Jonze

No one moves as effortlessly between highbrow and lowbrow projects as Spike Jonze. Best known for directing Being John Malkovich and Adaptation (let's ignore the long, quiet nap that was Where the Wild Things Are), this mensch has produced and directed commercials, TV shows, and music videos loved by the masses. And nothing is hotter than a man who can dance.

James Franco

James Franco

At thirty-two, he's been an actor, director, screenwriter, novelist, painter, and Gucci model. He's enrolled in five (five!) different elite graduate school programs — including Columbia and Yale — which would make any grandmother proud. I’d be tempted to say that it’s his brains and creative energy that make him sexy, but that would be overlooking his ass.

Andy Samberg

Andy Samberg

Garnering millions of views on YouTube and Hulu, Andy Samberg's Digital Shorts are the best thing about today's Saturday Night Live. His infectious comedy style is silly and accessible, and he makes the most out of the show's access to famous guests, no matter how talented — or not — they are. And so yes, Andy, I'd gladly take your dick in my box. (Sorry.)

Sacha Baron Cohen

Sacha Cohen

The actor/comedian/writer may keep kosher, but his flamboyant characters are anything but. Cohen confronts uncomfortable truths — racism, homophobia, and the stretch-marked horrors of a rural swingers’ party — without breaking character, and makes us laugh in the process. He also happens to be the only man in recent memory to appear totally naked on the cover of a major magazine.

Seth Rogen

Seth Rogen

He acts, he writes, he crowdsources for charitable purposes through Crowdrise.com. Whether he's schlubby or svelte, Seth Rogen is one of the most unassuming and underrated comedic talents in Hollywood. Also: he’s hot. When the lovely Katherine Heigl got pregnant and fell for him in Knocked Up, I had no trouble buying it.

Jon Stewart

Jon Stewart

Jon Stewart is smart, ballsy, and funny enough to keep us enraged but not despairing about the state of the world. He had my heart when he teared up on The Daily Show's first episode after 9/11 — and my loins when he said the terrorist attacks were no reason for racism and fear mongering.

Michael Chabon

Michael Chabon

Writer Michael Chabon is an undeniably hot piece of tuchus, especially if, like me, you get off on extended metaphors and genre experimentation. The Pulitzer Prize-winning author of The Amazing Adventures of Kavalier & Clay and The Yiddish Policeman's Union reportedly turned down being one of People's 50 Most Beautiful People. He was too busy raising four kids with his beautiful wife, Ayelet Waldman, with whom he is "famously in love."

Commentarium (39 Comments)

Sep 14 10 - 12:11am
Betty

No Joseph Gordon-Levitt? He'd be at the top of my list!

May 09 11 - 9:25pm
Camillaaa

AGreeeeed! Well at least...right below Mr. Franco

Sep 14 10 - 12:18am
Lisa

Love this, great list. My only correction would be that Sacha Baron Cohen is definitely not a "stand up guy." Have you heard the stories of that guy on set? And is James Franco really in the tribe?

Sep 14 10 - 12:23am
LC

Umm, no Eli Roth of "THE BEAR JEW" fame???

Sep 14 10 - 12:40am
RR

agree with LC, and i'm a straight dude

Sep 14 10 - 12:42am
RR

ps - while the gender-specificity of "mensch" is hotly contested, i think a feminine version of this list would be a hot contest i'd like to see

Sep 14 10 - 2:01am
elle

james franco is top on my list. bravo!
also i'd fuck colbert over stewart, but that's just me ; )

Sep 14 10 - 8:11am
Jack

Colbert is a Roman Catholic. The youngest of like 43 kids or something.

Sep 14 10 - 8:12am
Jack

I guess I should explain...being RC makes you very un-stand up.

Sep 14 10 - 10:04am
Penny

Kudos on Michael Chabon, very under-appreciated as a schtupable guy.

Sep 14 10 - 11:06am
Demanda

Has Gordon-Levitt really proved his menschiness yet? He's cute, yes. But I need like two more likable characters out of him.

Sep 14 10 - 11:52am
P.

Seth Rogen...sexy ugly!

Sep 14 10 - 11:53am
cincinatti

@Demanda, he started a website (hitrecord.org) that encourages and facilitates collaboration among artists, himself being one of the participants, and money from the monetized productions goes to the artists who contributed.

He's no overachiever, but I like that he is dedicated to a personal project (since 2002) off-camera + he seems to have a balanced perspective when it comes to what he does from what I've read -- just seems like a stand-up guy who happened to get famous doing something he loves.

But I never met him.

Sep 14 10 - 11:55am
LoveHandle

No way is Seth Rogen sexy ugly. He's just a little chubby.

Sep 14 10 - 12:36pm
anty

I agree - Joseph Gordon-Levitt is a serious miss... but you keep coming back for more Seth Rogen. I only have one thing to say about that...

Sep 14 10 - 12:45pm
aa

i love white men too!!!! omg.lol.

Sep 14 10 - 12:45pm
aa

white jews!!!

Sep 14 10 - 12:46pm
Kim

Hell yeah, Jon Stewart!

Sep 14 10 - 12:58pm
gianinna

ehh...
https://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=schtup

Sep 14 10 - 2:16pm
Tonjiboy

In Soviet Russia, mensches schtup you!

Sep 14 10 - 2:44pm
oy

What about Jeremy Piven?

Sep 14 10 - 3:11pm
LAP

Oh man, Where the Wild Things Are was an excellent film--I think children (or adults) of divorce will understand it best. It was a touching emotional picture of a preteen going through intense emotions.

Sep 14 10 - 4:08pm
DL

I love white jewish guys but wheres Jesse Eisneberg, Zac Efron, Andrew Garfield. add now please.

Sep 14 10 - 9:12pm
Annie

Chabon is beyond sexy. Great choice!

Sep 14 10 - 9:37pm
Genius

As a straight dude, I wholeheartedly agree... especially on James Franco. Holy moly.

Sep 15 10 - 12:15am
Riko

Where the FUCK is Paul Rudd???

Sep 16 10 - 5:20am
Shar1

Holy shit! I didn't know half these people were Jewish. SLURP! :-9 I agree on Joseph Gordon-Levitt, and probably would've chosen Nathan Englander or Jonathan Safran Foer over Michael Chabon, but it's definitely a matter of preference.

Sep 16 10 - 12:14pm
Kait

I hate the fact that sex with Seth Rogan is the punchline of not one BUT TWO FILMS. I'd hit like nobody shidduch.

Also, no Gyllenhaal?

Sep 16 10 - 1:45pm
LoveHandle

Chabon FTW. SafranFoer is just too precious.

Sep 16 10 - 5:29pm
Samantha

Did you have to pick all the ugly ones and call them "Hot", to boot? (i.e. Rogen). How about Zac Efron, Gabriel Macht, Logan Lerman, Gordon-Levitt (as someone said). James Wolk is a good one that's just starting out now.

Sep 18 10 - 3:11pm
WW

No Lenny Kravitz? For shame!

Sep 18 10 - 11:01pm
HOLY SHIT.

Slapping the bass rudd is jewish? Why the hell isn't he on this list? That man is beyond sexy. so is loveitt, nice one on samberg, stewart, chambo and franco though.

Sep 19 10 - 12:18am
DMC

I have to agree with everyone who said Paul Rudd. I saw him in person at a department store here in NYC and he is just divine.

Sep 20 10 - 9:18pm
LadyLove

What about Chris Pratt or Jason Segal or Paul Rudd...YOWZAS!!!

Sep 20 10 - 10:02pm
Samantha

Chris Pratt? Anna Faris' husband? I don't think he's Jewish. You probably meant Chris Pine, who is part Jewish.

Sep 22 10 - 10:46am
Destiny

If Paul Rudd and Jason Segel are Jewish, they seriously must be on this list. Yum. Also, Jesse Eisenberg, YES! Good to know I'm not the only one.

Oct 06 10 - 11:36pm
Juneau

Why isn't Adam Lambert on this list? Mega mensch, and both men and women want to schtup him.

Oct 07 10 - 12:01am
bogart

Adam Lambert a definite, and Jason Schwartzman!

Feb 07 11 - 2:36am
dee

no list of hot Jews is valid unless it has Logan Lerman on it somewhere, preferrably #1. He's my favorite 100% Jew.

Now you say something

Incorrect please try again
Enter the words above: Enter the numbers you hear: