Register Now!
  • In Other Blogs: Manny Being Manny

    The film blogosphere paid tribute to Manny Farber this week (Phil Nugent contributed our own obit here) and if that name doesn’t ring a bell, Glenn Kenny has some good advice at Some Came Running. “If you've never read Farber, just stop here and get to it. His collected criticism, in a volume called Negative Space, is one of the touchstone texts of film writing—tough-minded, sharp-eyed, idiosyncratic, often wildly funny, and with a bedrock integrity and aesthetic acuity that even best of contemporary film critics are hard-pressed to approach, let alone match. He is most often cited for coining the phrases ‘termite art’ and ‘white-elephant art,’ two opposed categories. What I found, and find, most valuable in his criticism is his ability to apprehend the entirety of a film—he got it from every angle. He could appreciate a B war picture in the same sense that the guy on the street could, while fully comprehending its value as a work of modern/contemporary art. I'm away from my study, so I can't grab a copy of Space to quote from it willy-nilly. But I can say this: I doubt that Farber was particularly surprised by Godard's Breathless, because his criticism actively anticipated that film.”

    David Edelstein has a personal remembrance at The Projectionist.

    Read More...


  • In Other Blogs: Seitz and Sounds

    If you felt the film blog world shift a little on its axis this week, it’s probably because The House Next Door founder and proprietor Matt Zoller Seitz has departed for greener pastures. Of all things, Seitz has decided to concentrate on making his own films. Can you imagine? Why, if we all did that, there’d be no one left to snark about our work.

    Seitz says goodbye with a lengthy interview with new House Next Door honcho Keith Uhlich, in which he discusses his plans as well as his lifelong love of movies. “There was this thing called The Scholastic Book Club, which I guess they still have because my daughter brings home the sheets for me to fill out. They had a book on the making of King Kong and I believe it was available before the movie had even come out. And I ordered it, along with some other things, and when it came I just read it from front to back. That was the first instance I can think of of my wanting to find out how movies were made. I don’t think I really knew anything about how movies were made. I just thought they were these things that kind of magically appeared on the screen when you went to the theater.”

    Tributes to Seitz have been proliferating ever since his announcement.

    Read More...


  • Slate's Movie Club Still Swinging

    Just when we think we’re completely burned out on year-end critic’s awards, list-making and assorted summations of What It All Means, along comes another installment of the Slate Movie Club to remind us how much fun it is to argue about this stuff. The annual roundtable of film pundits is always at its most entertaining when the gloves come off. The 2004 edition was particularly juicy, with original ringmaster David Edelstein and guests including A.O. Scott of the New York Times and Salon regular Stephanie Zacharek gleefully taking their shots at everyone’s favorite infuriating contrarian Armond White. (White’s style is accurately characterized by the Village Voice’s Dennis Lim as “entertainingly predicated on a bullying, unpredictable subjectivity.”)

    Read More...


  • Chicago Film Roundup, End-of-Year Edition

    Every month or so, the Screengrab bigwigs indulge me by allowing me to take a look at what's happening on the film scene in my beloved hometown of Chicago.  Here's what's up in the City of Big Shoulders:  in the Tribune, film critic Michael Phillips winds up the "2007 Chicagoans of the Year" feature in an interview with Juno screenwriter Diablo Cody, who, like many others, made what she calls "the mass exodus from cow college to Chicago" in order to spend a hipster sojourn in the big town before moving on to Minneapolis and, eventually, Los Angeles.  Cody discusses how living in Chicago shaped her writing and turned her into a raging cynic, an attitude that persisted through the early stages of Juno ("Oh, won't I be the little edgy-pants, writing a dark movie about a pregnant teenager") until its outlook was leavened into something more hopeful during the collaboration with director Jason Reitman.  In the Sun-Times, grand old man of Chicago film writing (and outspoken Iraq War critic) Roger Ebert takes a look back at William Wyler's celebrated 1946 naturalist post-war drama, The Best Years of Our Lives.  Calling for a more comprehensive DVD package of the film, Ebert claims that "as long as we have wars and returning veterans", the movie will not be dated.  He also discusses the film's down-to-earth approach, reflected in its visual storytelling:  "The film makes no effort to paint these men as extraordinary," he says of the wounded and psychologically damaged WWII vets who are its central characters.  "Their lives, their characters, their prospects are all more or less average, and Wyler doesn't pump in superfluous drama. That's why the movie is so effective...Wyler employed remarkable visuals to make some of his points. He was working with the great cinematographer Gregg Toland, known for his deep-focus photography on such films as Citizen Kane, and often Wyler uses deep-focus instead of cutting, so that the meaning of a scene can reveal itself to us, instead of being pounded down with close-ups."  Finally, over at the Chicago Reader, the big news surrounds the announcement that lead film writer/national treasure Jonathan Rosenbaum will be retiring from the weekly in February. Devotees eagerly await the official word, which will come next week in his best-of-2007 column (which is also expected to be his last regular column for the paper).  Although he will continue writing sporadically, the Reader's "On Film" section is already sparse, tissue-thin and infrequently updated; without Rosenbaum's sometimes frustrating but always intelligent criticism, it may lose a lot of readers it'll never get back.


  • Farewell, J.Ro... But Not Really.

    According to the Time Out Chicago blog, Chicago Reader film critic extraordinaire Jonathan Rosenbaum will be retiring from weekly criticism as of early next year. According to the TOC blog post, Rosenbaum's retirement will take place effective February 27, his 65th birthday, and that Rosenbaum will be officially announcing this in his upcoming best-of-2007 piece.

    Read More...


  • Chicago Film Writing Roundup

    On occasion, the Screengrab lets me bring you news from the rich world of film writing in my home town of Chicago. In the Tribune this week, foreign correspondent John Crewdson — inspired by Rendition — contemplates whether or not 'message' movies are really effective vehicles for spurring social change, and film blogger Michael Phillips talks to Mark Ruffalo about how his religious upbringing influenced his art. In the Sun-Times, Miriam Di Nunzio gets Malcolm McDowell to make the curious admission that he doesn’t think Caligula "is as bad as it once was" (has it somehow gotten better over the years?), and local legend Roger Ebert wins a Gotham Award from the Independent Feature Project. And in the Chicago Reader, Jonathan Rosenbaum, as part of his upcoming "Unseen Orson Welles" project, brings us the Italian neo-Marxist Giorgio Agamben’s choice of "the most beautiful six minutes in the history of cinema." — Leonard Pierce