This past spring I started dating a woman who was six years older than me and had three kids. I didn't have an issue with either of those things because I went into the relationship knowing about them. I also knew that she couldn't have any additional children — again, that was completely fine with me. Our relationship was great; we had a lot in common and our sex life was out of this world. Things kept going strong throughout the summer and into early fall. Then I didn't hear from her for a couple of days. She finally sent me an instant message telling me to leave her alone and stop talking to her, completely out of the blue.
A couple of weeks passed and we finally talked. She told me that I was the greatest lover she'd ever had and that I treated her right, but she thought that I deserved better, even though I told her she was exactly what I wanted. I keep asking her for another chance, but she tells me she's not sure. Some of her actions seem to indicate she'd be open to trying again, but she's not willing to give me a direct answer. Is there anything I can do or say? What do you think would be her reason for doing this? — Extremely Confused with Women
You want to know what I think, Extremely Confused? Honestly? I think she's bullshitting you. I'm a woman and I have no problem with getting something I don't deserve. Why yes, I will take the biggest piece of pecan pie. I will accept that easy job with the big fat raise!
I'm just your typical human being: I want what's best for me, not for you. In your ex's case, that means downgrading or ending the existing relationship with a minimum of guilt and confrontation. And what's better than "you deserve better"? It does triple duty: drops the axe, bolsters the fragile ego of the receiver, and makes the person doing the dumping look like a self-sacrificing saint. Do it right, and you may even be able to get some sympathy out of it, as the person being dumped tries to convince you of your greatness. Anyone who's been through a college romance or four knows that the only thing the ass-kissing and compliments do is give the dumper the confidence and emotional absolution they need to go out and pursue another relationship.
What you see here is avoidance, Extremely Confused, wrapped in gauzy pink window dressing. What's behind that curtain? Tough to say. Maybe she's cheating on you. Maybe she doesn't think you'd make a good father. Maybe she's back with the ex. Maybe she really does have low self esteem , but if it's that bad, then guess what? She's fucked up. You want someone happier and healthier. I'm sure she's nice — nice and fucked up are not mutually exclusive — but sometimes people aren't at a point in their lives where they can be a good mate.
Whatever her motive, it was way uncool to tell you over instant messenger. (What's next? Dumping by tweet?) Give her what she wants — in other words, space. You could take the typical pick-up-artist advice and be a huge dick; maybe she'll come running back. I could see that happening, but I could also see you getting hosed again a couple weeks later. If you want her back and you want it to last, you've got to back off and balance her personal limits with your patience: how much shit are you willing to put up with in the name of love? Only you (and perhaps Meatloaf) know that answer.
Readers, who else has been broken up with over instant messenger? Twitter? Skype? Telegram?
My boyfriend and I have been together for nine months. Everyone says that after that much time it's pretty normal to hit the point that we've reached — we fight over petty things, we fight over fighting, we fight over the same issues without solving them. We talked about "taking a break" to think about things and figure out how (or if) we want to work through all of this. My question is, what's the best, healthiest way to "take a break"? How often do we talk, do we still hang out, do we see other people ? I'm not interested in seeing other people, and I assume he isn't either. It all seems like such a grey area! — Ugh
Ugh is right. Breaks are the worst. No coffee. No donuts. Just pain. I remember going with an ex-boyfriend to a couples therapist. After hours of crying and fighting, we came in one Tuesday evening and announced we were "taking a break." We thought he would congratulate us for being so mature, perhaps call the other beards and elbow patches into his office for a look at his star patients. Instead, he asked, "Why?" A simple enough question, yet we didn't have an answer. We broke up for good a few sessions later.
I share this not only to let you know in a non-braggy way that I practice what I preach (P.S. — I'm totally bragging), but to emphasize the Why, how it's different from the How, and why both questions are equally important to your overall plan. I'm not saying you shouldn't hammer out whether it's acceptable to fuck other people — that'd be first on my agenda. "Assume" wouldn't be enough for me, no how, no way.
But be careful you don't dive into the logistics before asking the big, overarching questions: "Do I love this person?" and "Is this something I want to put my energy into?" and "Do I see a legitimate possibility of a future or has my gut already given me the answer and I'm just delaying?" Right now, you're probably both so wrapped up in the turmoil that you don't know the answers, but it's worth it to put this shit out on the table. For some couples it'll be a "Yeah, why are we doing this?" kind of moment. Others will use it as a base to go forward — still insecure and scared, but with a bit more clarity.
I can't give you an exact prescription because I only have a paragraph or two of information about your relationship. I do think that the most successful breaks are the ones where the couple has limited communication. They agree on a set of rules and trust the other person to follow them, adjusting only when they no longer feel workable or relevant. They don't use text and other forms of electronic communication to keep the drama addiction going, all the while claiming sobriety because they haven't had face-to-face contact. They put the relationship aside and put themselves at the center. They get independent lives, better lives than they had before. Then, hopefully, they come back together to renew their bond and share what they've learned along the way, while keeping gory details to a minimum.
Readers, what are your opinions on breaks? Should they be "anything goes" or are they a silly idea in the first place?
Have a question? Email . Letters may be edited for length, content and clarity.
Comments ( 38 )
Leave a Comment