Register Now!

Hooksexup’s Oscar Best Picture Trope Checklist

Twenty years of Best Picture winners, in convenient chart form!

The Academy Awards are approaching rapidly, and though this year’s ceremonies have been marred by Ratnergate, the Awards themselves probably aren’t going to break any new ground in terms of who wins what and why. In fact, if you take a macro view of the Best Picture winners of the past twenty years, you’ll start to see some familiar themes, which is why we’ve compiled this handy chart of Best Picture Tropes.

Now, if we look at the Best Picture Nominees for this year (The Help, The Tree of Life, War Horse, The Artist, Hugo, Midnight in Paris, Extremely Loud & Incredibly Close, and The Descendants), The Artist and The Help are the odds-on favorites, because they each fulfill three tropes (and because they could also be two different Brooklyn indie bands). While both films fulfill the Period/Historical Drama category, The Help's Grandiose Statement on Race could give it the edge over The Artist's A-Singin' and A-Dancin' (though it features considerably more of the latter than the former). But we're giving the edge to The Artist because it's A Good Cry, which edges out The Help's Punishing Run-Time for the third trope. 

Projected 2012 Best Picture Winner: The Artist

Commentarium (11 Comments)

Feb 22 12 - 4:48am
Alan

Was "orcs" really necessary?

Feb 22 12 - 8:17am
CJD

Orcs was the most necessary.

Feb 22 12 - 9:50am
Yoni

It was essential. This is great!

Feb 22 12 - 3:17pm
THC

I had to look up what ORCS meant. Very weak. Just like the franchise.

Feb 22 12 - 5:34pm
jcm800

Also, there were totally orcs in "Chicago."

Feb 22 12 - 11:13am
G Unit

Schindler's List excludes Grandiose Statement on Race - Fail.
LOTR Return of the King - Excludes Everything is horrible. - Fail

Feb 22 12 - 11:18am
TAL

I concur with G-Unit. Most of these films fulfilled more of the tropes than they were given credit for. The Artist already was a little known Indie band from Minneapolis in the late 90's. You know, as in little known for selling millions of records under the name Prince.

Feb 22 12 - 11:47am
rm

American Beauty had just about everything being bad, as I remember it.

Feb 22 12 - 2:50pm
mdd

doesn't it seem like war horse gets punishing run time, period piece, war=bad, & a good cry. thus it has four and should be the favorite.

Feb 22 12 - 2:57pm
julian.

Sometimes I remember that Crash won best picture, and then I lose all hope for humanity.

Feb 22 12 - 11:52pm
Heather

Agree with mdd, War horse has the most troupes on here. That should "be the favourite".

Now you say something

Incorrect please try again
Enter the words above: Enter the numbers you hear: