Register Now!

In Defense of Cindy "Cookie Monster" McCain

Posted by Emily Farris

 

Recently, Cindy McCain, wife of Republican presidential candidate Sen. John McCain, submitted a recipe to Family Circle for her oatmeal-butterscotch cookies. Only it turns out, they weren't exactly her oatmeal-butterscotch cookies. Or if they were her oatmeal-butterscotch cookies, they happen to be made the same way as someone over at Hershey's makes them — because the same recipe appears on the company's website.

Forgetting for a moment that oatmeal-butterscotch cookies sound pretty gross, I have to say, this kind of shit happens in the culinary world.

For example, I grew up thinking that my mom's green bean casserole was hers. It was creamy on the inside, crunchy on top and just plain delicious. Of course my mother had created it! Except, she hadn't. Once I started making it myself, I learned it was the recipe from the Durkee onion can. Was I devastated when I learned this? Sure. But had I not been writing a casserole cookbook and actually had to investigate and pay close attention to these things, would I have gone on thinking that my mom had created the green been casserole I grew up on? Probably. 

Unfortunately, as the Huffington Post reveals, the similarities are too close for comfort. McCain didn't even bother to change anything about the recipe, save taking the name Hershey's out of it. So unless her mother passed down this recipe without telling a young Cindy that it was ripped off from the company, it's possible Cindy ripped off Hershey's on her own. 

Now considering this isn't the first time the McCain clan has come under fire for stolen recipes, she should have been more careful. A few months ago, Cindy got in trouble for posting a Rachael Ray recipe as her own on John's campaign site.  

But can you blame her? With all the time she spends putting on her make-up do you think she really has the time to create recipes?

[Us: Cindy McCain, Bill Clinton Plagiarize Cookie Recipe, Website Reveals] 

Recently:

Spoon or Spork: Cindy McCain?

Top 5 Things McCain Should Do Now

Unauthorized Bio: McCain Had Awesome HS Nickname, Called Wife A "C-Word" In '92

Who Would You Rather: Nancy Grace vs. Rachael Ray?


+ DIGG + DEL.ICIO.US + REDDIT

Comments

LushlyMe said:

Why do we still act as if this is a relevant portion of a presidential election.  Are we really so naive that we think that the First Lady is a happy homemaker baking cookies for the President?  

June 17, 2008 5:03 PM

Maxwell Hammer said:

It's not that she stole it, it's just that copyright law is fucking stupid.

June 17, 2008 9:05 PM

nederick said:

While the high road would certainly be to say "whatever, it doesn't matter," you know that if Michelle Obama was caught lying about shit--stealing others' work and claiming it as her own "family recipes," she would get no such break from the other side.  

And aside from that, while it may not be a big deal, it's still lame and stupid and disingenuous.  The addition of the family recipes section of the website was surely a bid to make her seem like a homey, traditional wifey, but instead it's a calculated, unnecessary pose revealed as such.  It's uncomfortable that she (or whoever was responsible) would go there.  It's uncomfortable when anyone lies.  

June 17, 2008 9:25 PM

JCF said:

Politics aside, oatmeal butterscotch cookies are much more delicious than they sound!  Well, they are the way I make them anyway.  I don't know how Hershey makes them.  Just use an oatmeal cookie recipe with lots of brown sugar in it, and add butterscotch chips (or a mix of butterscotch chips and chocolate chips if you just can't stand the thought).

June 18, 2008 8:39 AM

bobb88 said:

It's pretty stupid to think Ms. McCain is suzie homemaker, but it's even dumber to copy recipes from well known websites virtually verbatim.

June 18, 2008 2:22 PM

About Emily Farris

Emily Farris writes about culture and food for numerous publications and websites you've probably never heard of, including her own blog eefers. Her first cookbook, "Casserole Crazy: Hot Stuff for Your Oven" was published in 2008. Emily recently escaped New York and now lives in a ridiculously large apartment in Kansas City, MO with her cat, but just one... so far.

in