Register Now!

Savage Love by Dan Savage

I'm a woman in my twenties, and I've been dating the love of my life for two years now. We are incredibly happy except for — guess! — we have different sex drives. When we first started dating, I initiated sex all the time and enjoyed it, but as soon as I started on birth control, my libido evaporated. After a nightmarish year of trying different methods, arguing with doctors, and hurt feelings, I decided that it wasn't worth it, and we've stopped using any hormonal birth control (we're using condoms).

But months later, I still have almost no interest in sex or masturbation. We have sex once or twice a week, but it's physically boring. I put on my game face and endure it. I enjoy pleasing him, but it does nothing for me. It hurts him that I am not interested in sex and that he can't arouse or please me. I want us to have a healthy sex life, because I love him and he's worth it. Could this still be the birth control? Did I somehow flip the OFF switch?

Please help, Dan. My doctors are all sex-negative and don't see the problem, and I want to enjoy sex again. — Not Horny, Not Happy

Your problem doesn't sound like a case of differing sex drives, NHNH, but like a healthy sex drive that's been derailed.

"Birth-control pills can decrease sexual desire if they substantially lower testosterone levels," says Cindy M. Meston, PhD, professor of clinical psychology at University of Texas at Austin and author of Why Women Have Sex. "The pill supplies a steady dose of hormones, so that the body stops producing its own unsteady, cyclical dose." The pill keeps your estrogen level high in order to prevent ovulation, while also "increasing the sex-hormone-binding globulin (SHBG), which binds to testosterone, thus blocking it from being 'read' by the body."

Testosterone plays a huge role in female libido, and blocking testosterone doesn't do your libido any favors. And while most women who experience a severe drop in libido on the pill bounce back a few months after they stop taking it, some women aren't so lucky.

"One well-regarded researcher, Irwin Goldstein, found that after stopping the pill, SHBG remained high in some women and testosterone levels didn't go back up," says Meston. "It's not common, but it could explain this woman's situation. The best thing for her would be to go to a gynecologist, urologist, or endocrinologist who specializes in sexual medicine (make sure they actually know what the hell they're measuring) and have all her reproductive hormones measured. If she's low in testosterone, she can take testosterone supplements."

That means you'll have to fire your current sex-negative doctors, NHNH, and find yourself some new, sex-positive ones — and you'll have to stick with them.

"She needs a good doctor to monitor her closely, as too much testosterone causes bad side effects in women — side effects like facial-hair growth."

I also shared your e-mail with Debby Herbenick, PhD, sexual-health educator at the Kinsey Institute and author of Because It Feels Good, and she feels there's a chance your problem isn't hormonal.

"In working with people, what I more often have found — and wrote about in my book — is something I call a 'cycle of dread.' I know that sounds 'magazine-y' but it's the best way I can think of to describe it, and this woman seems to epitomize it."

A cycle of dread — let's call it COD — can kick in when someone keeps having sex she doesn't want to have, or isn't enjoying, because she feels she must.

"Sometimes, it works out all right — once they start going, it feels better. But quite often, they don't want it, they do it anyway, it sucks ('physically boring,' 'I put on my game face'), and they do it anyway and keep doing it."

And COD, like SHBG, can flip your libido's off switch. So what do you do if COD's the issue?

"She should work with her partner," says Herbenick. "Talk about the situation, acknowledge that sometimes she doesn't want sex, or that type of sex." Herbenick believes a temporary "ban on intercourse" — or taking "vaginal off the menu," as I've recommended in similar circumstances — "can help couples learn to touch each other again with pleasure."

I think you should take the advice of both of our guest experts: initiate a ban on intercourse for now, NHNH, because you're not doing you, your libido, or your boyfriend any favors when you put on that game face and go through the motions, and go get your hormone levels checked.

What does a person do when an LTR starts to feel stagnant or boring or dull? — Partnered But Jonesing

A person experiments (with partner), cheats (on partner), or breaks up (with partner).

I have a dilemma. Even though I was born in 1972, people always assume that I'm in my mid-twenties. I tend to attract girls in their early twenties, and when they ask how old I am, I counter with "How old do you think I am?" They invariably guess an age that I haven't seen in more than a decade. When I tell these twenty-one- to twenty-three-year-olds the truth, it's a complete turnoff. Just last night I had to endure — that's endure, not Ensure — my third brush-off at the hands of a hot twenty-one-year-old girl in a row!

So what's an apparent senior citizen like myself to do? Do I just wait hopelessly for the dreaded question to come up? Do I blurt out "I'm old" as soon as a woman walks up to me? Do I take measures to try to look my age?

You're probably wondering why I don't just go for women closer to my own age. Here's why: women my own age tell me that they're looking for serious relationships and I look way too young for that and they worry that my looks mean I'm a total player! — You're Only Using Numbers, Girls

First, YOUNG, maybe your problem is the lousy puns. Endure/Ensure? That would earn you a brush-off from me.

But if older women aren't interested because you look too young, and younger women aren't interested because you are too old — if you're actually being discriminated against based on your age/looks — then you have a license to lie to women, young and old.

Let younger women think you're in your twenties until they get to know you better. Then disclose and apologize for the deceit without being too abject about it. You had cause. As for women closer to your own age, well, instead of telling them you're very nearly forty, YOUNG, let 'em think you're a twentysomething with a thing for older women. Then if a puma — or panther or cougar or otter or whatever — decides to dump you because she's getting too attached and the (presumed) age difference is simply too great, bust out your birth certificate, apologize, and propose.

CONGRATS: Two years ago, an openly gay student at Hudson High School in upstate New York ran for prom queen. He won — but school officials "denied him the crown." This year, two openly gay students — best friends, both boys — at Hudson High ran for prom king and queen and won "in a landslide." School officials didn't stand in their way, and Charlie Ferrusi and Timmy Howard got their crowns. Congrats to 2008's rightful prom queen, Augie Abatecola; congrats to this year's prom queen and king; congrats to the school officials who learned their lesson; and congrats to all the students at Hudson High.

Find the Savage Lovecast (my weekly podcast) every Tuesday at thestranger.com/savage.

Commentarium (19 Comments)

Jun 16 10 - 8:38am
Riley

Gay student becoming prom king, thats fine.

But it does seem a bit rough for a male student (regardless of sexuality) to take a title that is so coveted by the female students (at least it was at my high school), just to give some social message.

Of course, the gay prom king/ queen was probably voted for by the students anyway, so I guess no-one was really that worried.

Jun 16 10 - 10:17am
Balzac

You're Only Using Numbers needs to think about why what should be a blessing is a curse. Is he frequenting bars where only women in their early twenties will be? Is his position in and outlook on life closer to that of someone ten years his junior? Most of the women I know in their twenties are attracted to older men (myself included) and wouldn't find age to be a turn off unless it is paired with immaturity.

Jun 16 10 - 11:54am
Hooksexupsystem

For NHNH, if I found out my girlfriend was faking interest in sex, it would reduce my enjoyment too. I'd rather know about it, and work on a solution than keep pretending things are ok.

Jun 16 10 - 3:22pm
Angelfuk

To NHNH, I go through this same thing with my wife (both of us feel this way). You know what solves the problem....smoke some weed, have a beer, and it will all go away and you'll enjoy it again. I promise.

Jun 16 10 - 9:11pm
andy

"You're Only Using Numbers, Girls" - I could have written that one. 1972, check. Attract girls in their 20s, check. Shock and suprise when they find out I am old, check.

You just need to find girls in the late 20s, early 30s range, my friend. Try different events.

Jun 16 10 - 10:22pm
GDE

I could have written that first letter, but without the pills! It just went away. I don't know where it is. Maybe I will check into that COD thing.

Jun 17 10 - 8:52am
JCF

I don't recall having problems getting together with older women even when I really was younger. My guess is he should double-check to make sure he is wearing age-appropriate clothing (don't shop in the "Young Men's" section), and doesn't have a hairstyle that makes him look like a kid. I bet it's really an attitude problem, though, and the older women are using "too young-looking" as an excuse because it sounds nicer.

Jun 17 10 - 12:26pm
Nikki

Riley, who says getting the prom queen title was just done to give a social message? It's certainly within the realm of possibility that the young man running for prom queen really did want to wear that crown, just as much as an covetous female. The positive social message conveyed could have been just a wonderful plus. Boys can like tiaras, too. And there are plenty of girls that really didn't want to be prom queen. I'm one of them.

Jun 17 10 - 2:29pm
Meh

Because lying to women is a good idea.

Jun 17 10 - 4:06pm
iud

For me it took 6 months to a year for the sex drive to come back after being on the pill for about a year. I have the copper iud now, highly recommend it.

Jun 18 10 - 9:20am
Cam

Lying to women about your age? Not a great idea. They'll get the notion that you're willing to lie about trivial stuff in order to get with them, and that you're thus- surprise!- untrustworthy.
Better to be at least a little upfront, and maybe try frequenting bars with a wider age group.
Besides, I don't really buy that all these women are rejecting "Numbers" because he looks younger than he is. I know this because I'm 17 years older than my boyfriend, and neither one of us looks our real age (we both look a lot younger). The flipside for all of us, though, is that it sucks when people think you're one age and then react with shock and treat you differently when they find out the truth. So... maybe drop hints, play your cards a little close to the chest, but don't out-and-out lie. For what it's worth, when someone is bold enough to ask my age, I usually look them in the eye and say, "grown-up."

Jun 18 10 - 6:02pm
Lindsey

I have dated a lot of older men, including one 16 years my senior, who I met when I was 22. His age didn't bother me. But, it also didn't bother him. I have met other older men that I could've been attracted to, except they acted embarrassed about their age, drawing an undue amount to attention to the topic once it came up. If you don't want it to be a big deal, don't act like it's a big deal. Also, to me, when someone says "how old do you think I am?" it is too cutesy and a real turn-off. Same goes for lying. I find out you are lying to me over something as trivial as age, I will be skeeved out, won't trust you, and will stop seeing you immediately.

Jun 19 10 - 10:14am
kelly

To to 1st letter: There are different pills with different hormone combos. Try one low in estrogen (like triphasil or enpresse).

Jun 19 10 - 4:37pm
AB

umm....IUDs also emit hormones. What you're looking for is Paragard, the non-hormonal IUD.

Jun 20 10 - 9:59pm
ricochet

Yeah, because lying to anyone is better than being honest. What a crap answer. Savage, did you have some young thang phone that answer in for you? I can't wait to hear your lame defense of this answer. Because in all the years I've read your column I have NEVER heard a mea culpa. I don't expect to now. There are countless suggestions you could have given this guy (I've had the same trouble for years, although the young ones don't usually run away, they stick around until the novelty fades, which is kinda worse) but you tell him to lie. Stupid and ignorant.

Jun 22 10 - 1:49pm
@AB

that's why she said "the copper IUD" - it is ParaGard

Now you say something

Incorrect please try again
Enter the words above: Enter the numbers you hear: