Register Now!

As both seasoned politicians and eleventh-grade student-council presidents know, when coming up with a campaign slogan, it's probably best to avoid using one that's also been used by a white-supremacist hate group. GOP candidate Mitt Romney, however, apparently did not run for student-council president in high school. On Tuesday, AMERICAblog reported that one of Romney's most oft-repeated campaign slogans, "Keep America American," was also used by the Ku Klux Klan, who used the pithy catchphrase in their 1920s promotional materials. The slogan was first used in the 1850s by the Know Nothing Party, a nativist movement that aimed to protect jobs by curbing Irish-Catholic immigration. 

Although a spokesperson for Romney's office declined to comment on the story, it's probably safe to assume that Romney was unaware of the slogan's controversial history. Like most campaign slogans, "Keep America American" is superficially too vague to be offensive; divorced from its context, it sounds just as much like a slogan for toilet paper as it does a rallying cry for brutally violent white supremacists ("Keep America American: Wipe your butt with Charmin, made in the USA!").

It is, however, not totally outrageous to say that if this is the case, Romney — who has used the catchphrase in numerous rallies and campaign ads, including the one below — should have done more research into the history of, you know, the country that he's trying to be elected president of, before choosing a slogan that only your racist great-grandpa and Mel Gibson would probably approve of. 

Commentarium (5 Comments)

Dec 14 11 - 4:39pm
rm

Why do you assume he didn't know the connection, if not surely the connotation. He means it in the way you understand it.

Dec 14 11 - 4:47pm
Tolerance

I think the author is applying the principle of charity. We could explain Romney's choice of a campaign slogan either in terms of ignorance or as an attempt to align himself with a tradition of of racism and xenophobia. It's more charitable to assume that he was unaware of the use of the slogan by others, since the other explanation implies that he's a bad man.

Dec 15 11 - 9:19am
Doofus

At this point, even Al Sharpton says that this was an unfair smear on Romney. Nice going!

Dec 15 11 - 11:29am
mm

I can't think of any way to interpret "Keep America American" that isn't xenophobic.

Now you say something

Incorrect please try again
Enter the words above: Enter the numbers you hear: