Register Now!
 
LOG IN  |  SIGN UP
20

Sex Advice From Abstinence Pledgers

By Heather O'Neill

 

Anna, 31

Author of Sexless in the City

How can abstinence add to your sexuality?
"Abstinence" is kind of a tricky term, so I prefer to talk about sexual self-control — because that's what it really is. And one thing a healthy sexual self-control gives you is a fuller sense of what sexuality is. It's so easy to think of it as just being about intercourse, but there's so much more to being a man or a woman than that! Sexual self-control can really open your eyes to all that sexuality entails.

What are the main pitfalls of abstinence?
To talk about abstinence having "pitfalls" implies a somewhat negative view of it, as if it mostly has downsides. But if we talk in terms of sexual self-control, that changes. Certainly we can all think of examples of self-control exercised in an unhealthy way, but also many positive ways, such as the discipline of great musicians or athletes. Is there what economics would call an "opportunity cost" of their excellence? Sure. But no choice, sexual or otherwise, is free of a sacrifice of something else, even if you don't learn until later on what you gave up for it.

Sometimes the idea of getting a break from my boyfriend's libido sounds like Heaven. What is the best reason to date someone who has sworn off sex?
Taking sex out of the picture, at least temporarily, can bring a lot of clarity to things. If the person isn't trying to get sex out of you, it will probably give you a clearer picture of each other's character. And you can more easily evaluate things like: Is this someone I enjoy being around? Would I want to be with him or her when we've gotten lost in the middle of the desert?

My boyfriend caught me looking at girl-on-girl porn and freaked. I'm not a lesbian, I was just curious. How do I talk to him about it?
To talk about it in any kind of productive, meaningful way for the relationship, you're both going to have to dig beneath the surface a bit. What were your motives for looking? And what's behind his freak-out? Probably, what's behind his reaction will be a bigger factor than your motives, in fact, because the real issue is how he interpreted it, and the specters that raised for him.

What's the best way to introduce my ultra-conservative family to my tattooed, vegan girlfriend? I think they'd get along great, but I'm worried about these first impressions getting in the way.
She may have very different values from your family in a way, but there may be aspects of her character or sense of morality that are actually similar to theirs. Veganism is a pretty ascetic lifestyle and takes some serious discipline and commitment. Is that similar to things your relatives give up or are really committed to? Also, as staid as your family might seem, there are probably things they did in their youth, or people they dated, whom their families found very shocking. If you can get them to acknowledge and think back on that, you've laid decent groundwork for shrinking the gap between them and her. 

I lied to a girl I've been seeing about my job; I was embarrassed to say I just worked a register. We've been seeing each other for over a month now — how should I come clean?
Try to avoid bringing this up in a tense moment, first of all, but I would certainly tell her sooner than later. As long as you take the initiative to bring things up and can own up to your embarrassment, that ultimately reflects well on you. Hopefully she'll be big enough to recognize that, but be prepared for her to be somewhat taken aback by the deception and take it somewhat badly at first.

Comments ( 20 )

Heather seems like the most realistic/interesting of the bunch.

uh huh commented on Jun 11 10 at 12:17 am

anna reminds me of charlie, from high fidelity. her advice is correct, but it's not useful, and it's couched as if it's crucial that everything sound like a soundbite. how does this help anyone?

robert paulsen commented on Jun 11 10 at 12:23 am

"I'm going it for my future girlfriend"? I hope I am not one of his future girlfriends. I don't want a guy with an abstinence fetish.

Grady La-la commented on Jun 11 10 at 9:15 am

Anna really has a firm grasp on herself and life choices. Even though I may not agree, I really respect her responses.

Corabelle commented on Jun 11 10 at 9:56 am

Um, Brian, how do you know sex with the woman of your dreams will be great? Love does not always translate into erotic compatibility.

HotPinkSkirt commented on Jun 11 10 at 9:59 am

Heather is great. And she's right about the trial and error.

FriendofDorothy commented on Jun 11 10 at 10:03 am

Another vote for Heather, who's cute and unpretentious. Anna's obviously smart but poster #2 nailed it: all her answers sound like soundbites and have this weird, detached, impersonal quality. She sounds like a high-functioning aspie or a career politician.

meow mix commented on Jun 11 10 at 11:14 am

Anna definitely sounds like she is just reciting propaganda.

moops commented on Jun 11 10 at 11:31 am

anna scares the crap out of me

dj commented on Jun 11 10 at 12:38 pm

Anna reminds me of the girl from "Teeth"

boopsie commented on Jun 11 10 at 1:42 pm

If you're dating someone, but not having sex, isnt that just called "being friends?"

jewel commented on Jun 11 10 at 3:58 pm

"And after a couple years, all the emotional connection and built-up sexual energy makes the first time the best sex you've ever had."

Or more likely, a premature ejaculation and a return to celibacy. Sex is like any other skill, it gets better with practice.

DJC commented on Jun 11 10 at 4:01 pm

How do these people go without getting laid? I both respect and fear it, and think they can't really have much of a sex drive.

Eric commented on Jun 11 10 at 7:42 pm

Biggest fallacy: one who stays abstinent is doomed to bad sex. By chance, I've only had one partner and our sex is fantastic because we've had a while to get in sync. Was it awkward at first? Yup. Are we great now? Yup. We built it on good communication, not trying sex with a bunch of people and settling on the one that fucks the best...

Besides, if you were having 'bad' sex, how would you know you weren't having 'good' sex? From porn? From numerous random sexual experiences? Still haven't figured that one out...

M commented on Jun 11 10 at 7:48 pm

While I understand where you are coming from (a place where people judge you negatively for being abstinent), I still feel like your tone is very judgmental "M". As if people who have multiple sexual partners are so shallow that they would throw away any emotional attachment and just settle for the best in bed.

Bad sex is identifiable based on personal preference and other individual factors. I knew I had bad sex the first time and I can differentiate between someone who cares about my needs and kinks and satisfying it.

You say it as if people who fuck around could never achieve the zen you have with your singular partner when that is exactly the opposite.

Dee commented on Jun 11 10 at 10:59 pm

Zen? Yikes no. We're definitely a work in progress. And I don't mean to be judgemental - heck I'm a regular Hooksexup reader. Agree that good and bad sex exist, as much as healthy and unhealthy relationships exist,.. now I'm starting to sound like grandma. Hat tip to the folks for going out on a limb with this article.

M commented on Jun 11 10 at 11:45 pm

No worries, M. Just wanted to clarify, haha. But that is the point of assuming good intention in terms of internet discussions.

Dee commented on Jun 12 10 at 9:41 pm

Wow, you misread terribly Dee! I am very impressed that your desire to be Very Offended managed to overcome your brain.

susieqtip commented on Jun 12 10 at 11:35 pm

Abstinence is like vegetarianism. I don't mind it in practice, but when people make it the main part of their identity it gets tiresome.

smoog commented on Jun 13 10 at 9:32 am

Getting sex advice from someone who practices abstinence is like getting restaurant advice from someone who is anorexic.

LT commented on Jun 14 10 at 1:48 am

Leave a Comment